Summary: A panel of physicians says vitamin supplements and multivitamins are generally a waste of money for the average, healthy person, and some vitamin supplements can be unhealthy. [Author: Brady Hartman. This article first appeared on the LongevityFacts.com website. Follow us on Reddit or Google+ ]
Advice on vitamins frequently changes, with one report contradicting the next. In 2013, a group of physicians decided to answer the question “are multivitamins necessary?” and put an end to the controversy. After reviewing the mounting evidence against multivitamins and vitamin supplements, the group published their conclusions in the Annals of Internal Medicine (AIM), a top medical journal. In an editorial titled “Enough is Enough – Stop Wasting Money on Vitamin & Mineral Supplements,” the physicians declared that supplement usage was usually ineffective and sometimes harmful.
Article In A Nutshell
In case you are short of time, here’s a short summary of this article.
- After analyzing studies of nearly 500,000 people, the AIM editorial concluded that daily use multivitamin and other vitamin supplements don’t help well-nourished people with healthy diets. Taking multivitamins, minerals or vitamin supplements didn’t reduce heart disease, cancer or the risk of death.
- The authors of the AIM editorial didn’t analyze the benefits of vitamins on people with vitamin deficiencies or at-risk of deficiencies. They mainly focused on people who were already well-nourished and also taking vitamin supplements.
- The AIM study authors said that some vitamins shortened lives when consumed in excess.
Americans Can’t Seem To Get Enough Multivitamins
Americans have been taking multivitamin and mineral supplements since the products arrived on the market in the early 1940s. Multivitamin and mineral supplements, called multivitamins for short, are popular supplements taken by approximately one-third of all Americans. Multivitamins comprise 40% of all supplement sales.
Researchers have had a difficult time studying the effects of multivitamin consumption because no there is no standard definition as to what actually constitutes a multivitamin supplement. No definition declares what product must contain nor at what levels. Therefore, the term multivitamin refers to ‘multivitamin /multi mineral products with widely varying compositions’.
The AIM Review on Vitamin Supplements
For the general population, the AIM panel concluded that taking vitamin and mineral supplements was a hazard to some and a waste of money to most. The panel of physicians, led by Edgar Miller, M.D., a professor of medicine and epidemiology at Johns Hopkins University (JHU), analyzed over 40 long term clinical studies on vitamins and supplements with a combined total of around 500,000 study participants.
The AIM panel conducted a study of studies, called a systematic review, in which they systematically analyzed all the published evidence on vitamins and supplements, and then pooled the results. Systematic reviews are among the strongest forms evidence because they average the results of large numbers of research reports with different conclusions.
The AIM Study Conclusion
The AIM panel got the bulk of their evidence from an earlier investigation on supplements performed by Fortmann and colleagues for the USPTF, which had reviewed the supplementation trials of 400,000 participants. The AIM panel summarized their conclusions in a short paragraph, stating:
The message is simple: Most supplements do not prevent chronic disease or death, their use is not justified, and they should be avoided. [emphasis mine]. This message is especially true for the general population with no clear evidence of micronutrient deficiencies, who represent most supplement users in the United States and in other countries [emphasis mine]
The panel members concluded the editorial declaring that supranormal doses of vitamin E, beta-carotene, and vitamin A supplements are harmful to one’s health, stating: “In conclusion: beta-carotene [supplements], vitamin E [supplements], and possibly high doses of vitamin A supplements are harmful.” The authors added that other common vitamin supplements, such as “other antioxidants, folic acid and B vitamins, and multivitamin and mineral supplements” are ineffective when used by the general population for the purposes of improving health, living a longer life, or preventing chronic diseases.
The AIM panel said that while there may be exceptions for vitamin and supplement usage by certain small subgroups of the population, their conclusion was:
“supplementing the diet of well-nourished adults with (most) mineral or vitamin supplements has no clear benefit and might even be harmful. These vitamins should not be used for chronic disease prevention. Enough is enough.”
Caveats of the AIM Study
The AIM panel relied heavily on evidence generated by what I’ll term the Fortmann / USPSTF review. The Fortmann / USPTF study was a large systematic review of 400,000 participants. Fortmann and colleagues admitted the caveats of their study, namely:
- The Fortmann / USPTF examined the effects of taking supplements for less than 10 years. It takes far longer than ten years for cardiovascular disease and cancer to develop. Instead, these diseases develop over a lifetime.
- They mainly analyzed studies in which vitamin and multivitamin supplements were given to well-nourished adults. The authors said: “our results do not apply to the targeted use of nutrients [vitamin and mineral supplements] in deficient or higher-risk individuals.”
- The Fortmann / USPSTF review concluded that supplements did not reduce the incidence cardiovascular disease, cancer, and death. However, they didn’t report on unmeasurable outcomes like ‘improved vitality.’
Nutritional Insurance or Nutritional Sledgehammer?
Some people use a multivitamin as a form of nutritional insurance. Taking a multivitamin helps these people obtain recommended intakes of the vitamins and minerals they don’t obtain from food alone.
Although multivitamins can improve one’s intake of various vitamins and minerals, they can also increase the likelihood that they will exceed safe levels of other vitamins and minerals, acting like a nutritional sledgehammer.
IWHS says Multivitamins Increase Mortality
The Iowa Women’s Health Study (IWHS) tracked the supplementation habits of more than 38,000 women, aged 55 and up, for nearly 20 years. The researchers tallied up deaths at the end of the study period and published their results a few years back.
To everyone’s surprise, the IWHS authors concluded that taking daily multivitamin supplements increased the risk of death by a few percentage points. Another surprising finding was that the woman in the study who habitually consumed multivitamins had better health habits than those that didn’t.
Research supports this. A study by Cheryl L Rock, from the Department of Family and Preventive Medicine, University of California, San Diego found that multivitamin users eat far healthier, and get more vitamins and minerals from their diet than nonusers. The people who need multivitamins the least are the most likely to take them.
Correlation Does Not Imply Causation (but it sure is a hint.)
Take the findings of the IWHS study with a grain of salt, because it was merely an observational study. Observational studies are considered to be a weaker form of evidence than gold-standard randomized clinical trials.
Instead of trying to fix a poor diet with vitamin supplements, it’s far healthier to obtain them from a well-balanced diet, a diet full of fruits and vegetables.
Plant-based foods are a healthier source of vitamins and minerals. As well, they contain other compounds, called phytonutrients. As a related article shows, a diet rich in fruits and vegetables helps prevent chronic diseases like stroke, cancer, and heart disease and has also been to shown to reduce the risk of death by 31%.
Some Vitamin Supplements Are Harmful
While the IWHS Study used weaker evidence, the AIM Review relied mostly on gold-standard randomized controlled trials. Back in 2013, the AIM panel members concluded that high doses of vitamin E, beta-carotene, and vitamin A supplements are harmful. A related article, shown in the link below, adds more vitamins and one mineral to their list, as well adds new evidence from a recent study.
Related Article: Top Five Deadly Vitamins
Take Home Message
The evidence from dozens of research studies, covering nearly half a million people shows that vitamin supplements, including multivitamins, don’t ward off chronic diseases for the well-nourished American with a healthy diet. In fact, some vitamins and supplements are harmful. Claims that vitamin supplements prevent cancer, heart attack and premature death in the general population are not supported by strong evidence. Vitamins and supplements, while helpful to people with specific deficiencies are a waste of money most of the general population.
Related Article: 8 Answers To Top Questions About Vitamins and Supplements
Help Us Spread the Word On Facebook
Please help us spread the word about vitamin supplements. To share this article it only takes one simple click on the Facebook link on this page.
1) Diagnosis, Treatment or Advice: This article is intended to inform and educate and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, nor for the diagnosis or treatment of any medical condition. Do not stop or start taking a vitamin or mineral supplement based on something you may have read in this article. Instead, seek the advice of a qualified, licensed physician with any questions you may have regarding vitamin supplements or a medical condition. Consult with a doctor before significantly changing your diet, starting or stopping a mineral or vitamin and supplement regimen. 2) Organization/Company Names, External Links & Photos: This article is not intended to endorse organizations, companies or their products. Links to external websites, mention or depiction of specific organizations, companies or brands are intended for illustration only and does not constitute an endorsement.